(c-note: im posting this without proofreading it, cuz i have to run and i dont want this to be an unfinished post.)
i have something important to say!
this post is based on my having just watched episode four ('the power and the people') of
new york: a documentary film.**
episode four covers the
triangle factory fire. (
as always, wikipedia has a good concise description of this tragic event.)
for those unfamiliar with the triangle fire, here's the opening paragraph from wikipedia:
The Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire in New York City on March 25, 1911, was a major industrial disaster, causing the death of 146 garment workers who either died in the fire or jumped to their deaths. The fire led to legislation requiring improved factory safety standards and helped spur the growth of the International Ladies' Garment Workers' Union, which fought for better working conditions for sweatshop workers in that industry.the garment workers were mostly - if not all - teenage women - girls, who worked ridiculous hours under disgusting conditions and basically defined the term 'sweat shop.' the tragic, disgraceful catalyst for the horror was the fact that the doors to the floor where the fire was were locked by the factory owners, preventing the girls' escape. (ostensibly, the exits were locked to encourage labor and to prevent stealing.)
anyway, i had long known about this event, but i had never been fully aware of the grisly, bloody scope of that day until i saw this episode of
new york.
the film's narrators read from first-person accounts of the fire. word of the fire spread around the city quickly, and many bystanders came down to watch the event unfold. sadly, no one could really do anything to help any of the girls. firefighters' ladders and hoses simply could not reach the upper floors of the building. so those who were there eventually realized that they were not going to see a rescue; they were only going to see a slow, agonizing tragedy. needless to say, it was brutal.
there were multiple first-person accounts that spoke of watching girls crowd in the open windows of the doomed high floor, with flames jumping behind them, nipping at them. accounts of watching girls jump individually, and also holding hands. accounts of realizing that since there was no way out, all the girls in all the windows would eventually have to jump, with no hope of survival. accounts of girls in mid-air, fluttering their arms to right their bodies. in vain.
the
new york film was released in 1999.
this i swear to you - if i played certain excerpts of these first-person accounts for you - the accounts of girls crowding windows and jumping - you would never be able to tell if the account was of the triangle factory fire of 1911, or 9.11. realizing this was one of the most eery feelings i've ever experienced. (i havent seen the last episode of the film, which was made after 9.11 to accomodate the event. i dont know if the film draws this parallel at that point.)
this transcendent parallel of the two single greatest tragedies in nyc's history got me to thinking.
it took a while, but the triangle fire served as the catalyst for great labor reform, and even the women's movement. progress was slow--laws were not changed immediately, but one could fairly say that eventually, crucial measures including key safety and workers’ compensation laws were borne out of the triangle fire.
thinking about
this kind of depressed me.
b/c the thing is, while new york city seemed to have 'learned something' from the triangle fire, we don't seem to have 'gotten the message' from its recent analog, 9.11.
sure, in the days, even weeks, even months following 9.11, the city took on a different vibe. people really were more copacetic with each other, and i genuinely felt a unity here i had never experienced previously in my 20 odd years living on the rock. but now, in nyc, it feels practically like 9.11 never happened. it's business as usual.
sure, the US went after osama and the taliban pretty quickly. sure, we waged a war on terror.
but, to say nothing of how silly the 'war on terror' really is, we, nyc, didn't really learn the right lesson: a lesson pretty similar to the fire of 1911.
in short, both events should have spurred new york to protect its needy, downtrodden citizens, but only one event did.
make no mistake, 9.11 was more about poverty and desolation than 'terrorism' (yes, i know this idea is not original, but still). the plain truth is that if there weren't hopeless people in the middle east who don't have a proverbial pot to piss in, there wouldn't be terrorists attacking us, with our proverbial streets paved with gold.
im not saying new york should have responded to 9.11 by extending aid to the middle east. that doesn't seem to fit. but why not take the underlying lesson from 9.11--poverty and hopelessness hurt us all--and apply an antidote to those forces here, in nyc?
why didn't we, as galvanized new yorkers, stand up and say 'we will alchemize this tragedy. we will learn from it, just as we did from the triangle fire. we cant necessarily help people all over the world, but we sure as hell can help people in the five boroughs. more of us can volunteer at shelters, more of us can volunteer at needy schools....'
sure, some people did take it upon themselves to do these things, but where was the gestalt movement? where was bloomberg truly championing these ideas, with the full weight of his office, and even wealth? where was bloomberg putting radical new laws into effect which would aid the needy?
he/we had so much inherent political capital from 9.11. im not saying we didn't do anything, but we didn't do enough. of that i am sure.
the triangle fire produced sweeeping, once-in-a-generation labor reform. where is our reform? what will we tell our kids 9.11 was good for? a war? a conspiracy theory? a few movies?
all there was/is was an eye-for-an-eye military response by the US as a whole, and a year-long (give or take some mos.) campaign of faux born-againism by new yorkers, mostly taking shape as tacky american flags taped to apartment doors.
i see as many homeless people as ever. i see as many beggars on the subway. i feel just as much racial tension. it's the new york i grew up in and i love it, but--aye, there's the rub.
i dont want to tell my kids that the new york i grew up in didn't change on account of 9.11. i want to be able to tell them that before 9.11, there was a lot of poverty and hopelessness here, but 9.11 taught us something, and we fought like hell to change all that after the tragedy. just like they did after 1
911.
what reforms will i be able to point to? i want to be able to say 'that's how mike bloomberg got his universal new york health coverage bill passed' or 'that's when it was mandated that every neighborhood had to have a homeless shelter of certain quality.' but i fear i wont be able to say SHIT.
i know i sketch some broad strokes here, but i think/hope you get my point.
i wouldn't say we're letting the terrorists win. but by responding in kind to them, rather than fixing the wounds we already had--the wounds the poor, hopeless terrorists illuminated for us--we're making this battle a push (tie) at best.
let's learn our lesson, new york. let's honor the people who, hopeless, jumped from the trade towers. let's honor them by giving strength and help to the hopeless new yorkers who are not jumping, but dying the slow death, every day, month upon month, year after year.
we see them every day. they should be our proxies for the people we couldn't save in battery park. and we have much more time to help them. right now, we aren't doing NEARLY enough.
let's change this city in a goddamn
tangible way. radical reform, not the wish that every new yorker now has that fuzzy feeling in his heart that we all should be on level ground. let's fucking level the ground.
fulcrum and pivot have mostly overlapping definitions. but i use them here to mean different things. a fulcrum is a pt on which a great swing is made. a lever is pulled. something changes. in basketball, a player with the ball can pivot on one foot as much as he likes, but he does it to throw the defense off. he never actually moves anywhere.
let's make 9.11 a fulcrum, not a pivot. we did in 1911.
100 years apart, new yorkers watch a nightmare come true for fellow new yorkers.
** - (i dont know if ive endorsed this seven disc series here before or not, but in any case im gonna do so now. if you live in nyc, you
must netflix or buy the film immediately, because it will open your eyes and heart to the city in a whole new way, and you will be grateful for this. if you just
like nyc, you must do the same. if you're remotely
interested in nyc, you must watch it. even if you hate nyc you should watch it to gain the respect for the city you're so sorely lacking. basically, everyone should see this film -- it's spectacular and epic. it's eptacular.)